Home » Entertainment » Which was better, the movie or the book?

Which was better, the movie or the book?

Maggie M. Adan | Published: Nov 4, 2009 - 8:00am

davinci

davinci1The Da Vinci Code, 2006

Book: Symbologist Robert Langdon uncovers an ancient secret that will shake the very foundations of Christian belief and will reveal the truth about the Holy Grail. But a powerful organization will do anything to keep this secret a secret, and he has to outsmart them if he wants to get to the truth and stay alive.
Movie: Let us put it this way: Tom Hanks is no Robert Langdon.
Verdict: Definitely the book. Although the movie is pretty decent and we all love us our Tom Hanks, he and Tautou are completely miscast. And you know something is seriously off when the action scenes are more thrilling in print than in the movie.


twilight

twilight1Twilight, 2008

Book: Bella, a typical teenager, catches the eye of the brooding and mysterious Edward Cullen. They fall madly in love despite the fact that he's a vampire.
Movie: The movie pretty much sticks closely to the plot of the book, even copping some of the more popular lines (i.e. the lion and the lamb). It sent the careers of its stars Robert Pattinson, Kristen Stewart, and Taylor Lautner soaring into the stratosphere. Its sequel, New Moon, will be out this month.
Verdict: It's hard to say. We're fans of both, no doubt about it. But we are well aware of the book and the movie's glaring weaknesses. One of which is that there's enough sap in it to put the maple syrup industry out of business. But we can't help ourselves. Both the book and the movie are serious (very) guilty pleasures.


Tags: books   Movies   twilight  
Username   * required
Security Image Security Image  * required
 
NOTE: SPOT.ph editors reserve the right to moderate and delete comments, without notice, that contain abusive or threatening behavior, contain advertising, spam, profanity or malicious comments.
Filter comments by:
  • kkkatsky22 Dec 17 2010 @ 05:23pm Report Abuse
    am a BIG fan of the HARRY POTTER series, book and fiLm version :Drni ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ JODI Picoult's MY SISTER's KEEPER, but abigail BRESLIN is amazing..:D
  • Mookie-Mookie Nov 14 2009 @ 05:21pm Report Abuse
    The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini
  • kei_em Nov 10 2009 @ 11:08am Report Abuse
    twilight... 'nuff said.
  • relapsing Nov 08 2009 @ 10:42pm Report Abuse
    For me, book always trumps movie. Reading lets your own imagination run wild with the author's words. Turning a book to a movie is tough because there'll always be a question of how loyal the movie was to the book, and how far the movie must stray from the book to please both readers and non-readers. I have high hopes for The Lovely Bones adaptation though.

    And anon - high five! :)
  • grow up Nov 05 2009 @ 10:23pm Report Abuse
    Isn't Twilight for adolescents?
  • anon Nov 05 2009 @ 06:54pm Report Abuse
    have to agree with gecko. the list has too many chick flicks on it. Wouldn't mind having a horror flick/novel featured. Or any older movie would have been nice too. Say Love Story?

    And you really can't choose between Twilight movie/book. They both sucked.

    "special effects were nothing to sneeze at" -- for LOTR

    how about creating an entirely new language? No matter how good the visuals of the movie were, it wouldn't be able to match the sheer brilliance of Tolkien's work.

    Great topic and props for the effort though.
  • add a comment Nov 04 2009 @ 10:33pm Report Abuse
    a good book is sacrificed for those who cannot at least conceive or as always to cater the purse at their expense.
  • indierock Nov 04 2009 @ 09:00pm Report Abuse
    Twilight? Seriously?!
  • platinumangel Nov 04 2009 @ 03:09pm Report Abuse
    The Devil Wears Prada. Meryl Streep was just amazing! :)
  • poleng Nov 04 2009 @ 12:29pm Report Abuse
    Of all the Harry Potters, only Goblet of Fire and Pisoner of Azkabhan edged out the book versions. Only because, for Goblet, Rob Pat is in there and guys from Pulp and Radiohead had funny cameos as Weird Sisters.
    Tony Takitani - Saw this one at the Eiga Sai fest last July. Remained faithful to the Murakami short. More like an audio book.

    Roald Dahl based movies: Matilda? Charlie and Chocolate Factory??? When will the Americans leave this beloved British author alone? James and the Giant peach is Ok and i haven't seen Fantastic Mr. Fox. But judging from the trailer of Mr. Fox, I think it's gonna be a great movie if its not a Dahl's classic adaptation.

    Worst adaptation;
    My Sister's Keeper. The different ending was the least bothersome about the film.
  • George Nov 04 2009 @ 11:39am Report Abuse
    Silence Of the Lambs bu Thomas Harris. The book is better but the movie nails the mood and atmosphere big time!
  • gecko Nov 04 2009 @ 10:56am Report Abuse
    "No disrespect to J.R.R. Tolkien, but the movie trumps the books. The books are excellent, but they require focus and determination."

    So the movies are better because they don't require focus and determination? What?

    The movies has great visuals, yes, but the books win by its sheer brilliance, inventiveness, and imagination.

    Plus I would willingly kick out one of the chick lits for a comparison of the Narnia books to the movies, because CS Lewis is more relevant.
1 to 12 of 12
 
Search    ARTICLE   ESTABLISHMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

yes...it is ewww...yuccckkk......nothing more.....hahahahahaha

bruce lee - February 4, 2012 | 11:42am

READ THE ARTICLE - P-Noy, Grace Lee attend Manila Bulletin anniversary party

di naman talaga maitatapat ang budoy at impeachment trial, cuz former is a teleserye, scripted; latter one is real life where the truth is really hard...

bakit - February 4, 2012 | 10:51am

READ THE ARTICLE - "Hindi mo pwede itapat sa Budoy ito," says former senator Kit Tatad on the Corona impeachment trial's "bore factor"

This is not so true.please Lang.

Msbillions - February 4, 2012 | 8:19am

READ THE ARTICLE - Psychic predicts Kris Aquino will have another child, then will become PH president

Lets ask Palau Embassy for confirmation to Palau president are the fact is true it is a gift to them? If it is not true you have to face law against...

Extinction Preventer Association - February 4, 2012 | 1:29am

READ THE ARTICLE - Davao City mayor Sara Duterte slams Korean vessel owner, crew, and passengers for eating endangered sea turtle

Dapat pagbutihin ng mga teachers sa Filipino ang pagtuturo sa subject at gawing kaakit-akit sa mga estudyante. At bakit ba nawala ang paglalagay ng...

Myles - February 3, 2012 | 11:35pm

READ THE ARTICLE - PH youth finds difficulty reading and writing in Filipino

SHOPPING+SERVICES
CHECK IT OUT: Jing Si Books and Cafe in Binondo
Exploring Binondo? Check out this haven for books and CDs on Buddhist teachings, eco-friendly products with a small cafe serving vegetarian food.
EAT+DRINK
10 Steals and Deals This Week
Coffee-and-cake combos at Chocolate Fire for P200, chicken-all-you-can at Max's Las Piñas for P199, and more!
EAT+DRINK
CHECK IT OUT: Cafe Publico in Greenhills
This cozy gelateria serves funky flavors like Thai Tea, Black Samurai, and Peanut Butter and Jelly.
ENTERTAINMENT
10 Movies to Watch This Month
Daniel Craig and Rooney Mara in The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, George Clooney in The Descendants, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace in 3D, and more!
EAT+DRINK
CHECK IT OUT: Ramen Cool in Kapitolyo, Pasig
Liempo and salmon in your ramen bowls? Ramen Cool says it can be done.
ENTERTAINMENT
10 Things to Do This Weekend
SPOT.ph zeroes in on the events you shouldn't miss.
ENTERTAINMENT
Where to Go Tonight: The Bar & Club Scene This...
Your handy guide to the metro's hottest gigs and parties.
VIDEOS
Lourd de Veyra's modeling debut in Cosmo's January issue
Lourd trades t-shirts for sixties-style suits.
VIDEOS
Ford Supermodel of the World Danica Magpantay stars in her...
The young model is Globe Tattoo@Home's newest brand ambassador.
VIDEOS
Videos of Ate Vangie, the "Pinoy Siri" go viral
Meet "Vangie," the Taglish-speaking virtual assistant who can help you combat Manila traffic jams, make Pinoy spaghetti, and more.
VIDEOS
Juana Change pokes fun at the "little girl" in latest...
"They are plotting to kill me," says Juana Change as Gloria Arroyo in new vid.
VIDEOS
Juana Change's Christmas 2011 Video: "Iba't-ibang Mukha ng Pasko"
No nega vibes here: Juana Change parties with kids in her new Christmas video.
VIDEOS
Bea Alonzo gets groovy in Preview's holiday video
Join Bea and The Bang Bangs as they backtrack to the '60s in this very mod holiday music vid!
VIDEOS
Be the life of the party with Petra Mahalimuyak's latest...
This 19-year-old comedian shows off dance moves that would put J.Lo to shame.
VIDEOS
Charice tackles bravery in latest video, “Louder”
Now more grown up than ever, Charice shows the world how to soldier on despite adversity.