Home » Entertainment » Movie Review: New Moon is better than Twilight

Movie Review: New Moon is better than Twilight

Jansen Musico | Published: Nov 20, 2009 - 11:14pm


new-moon-pattinson2

Vampires don't glitter. Whoever thought of such an asinine idea deserves a good bop on the head; and in the case of Stephenie Meyer, emergency brain surgery. Ever since Twilight ravaged the big screen last year, the media suddenly hopped on the Vampire Express, reducing the once mysterious denizens of night into daft, emotive metrosexuals with soft spots for equally emotive damsels in distress. The prequel stretched any unwilling moviegoer to absolute extremes of mush and unwarranted hilarity, a mix that obviously worked on the movie's die-hard fan base of pubescent girls. It was with this dim mindset that I entered the cinema, keeping my fingers crossed that New Moon would be twice as absurd as its predecessor–I needed a good laugh.

The film starts with a pale-faced Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) standing in a woodland clearing, waving to her grandmother. From the shadows walks an even paler Edward Cullen (Robert Pattison), skin glittering in shining-shimmering splendor under the soft rays of sunlight. Ladies and gents, we have officially entered the cheesy world of Twilight.

Staying true to its prequel, the first 20 minutes feeds the audience with heaping servings of unadulterated cheese. I can't help but laugh out loud amidst a smitten crowd of crazed fangirls when Edward Cullen, donning his trademark glare, utters the words, "You give me everything just by breathing." And, like clockwork, the sentimental piano score booms from the background. I swear I can hear whimpers from the crowd as the two star-crossed lovers part ways. Forever, I hope.

new_moon_jacob_black_poster-2Just when I am about to write the movie off as a slightly-polished twin of the first, the plot gets a much needed shot of adrenalin as we are introduced to a slew of new faces in the form of strapping young werewolves, shirtless throughout the movie, and an unearthly intimidating group of elite super vampires called the "Volturi." The casting choices are perfect, treating the audience to a mix of notable stars and complete unknowns. The standout in this ensemble is a silent Dakota Fanning who plays Jane, a vampire whose demeanor is as fierce as her blood-red eyes.


I find it amazing how the Cullen family's absence in 80% of the film flips the whole mood around. The skies are less drab, the songs less sentimental, and the exchange of lines less cringe-worthy. In this movie, the emotive vampire family plays second-fiddle to the alpha pack of werewolves and Jacob Black (Taylor Lautner). For a 17-year-old, Lautner surprisingly plays his part well, giving moderated doses of violence and tenderness to his character. His pairing with Bella, dare I say, is actually more believable than her hollow supernatural connection with Edward. The storyline becomes richer, its progression filling the voids left by the first flick.

The movie still does have its faults though, with several booboos in pivotal scenes; the most laughable one being the film's climax set in Volterra, Italy where a desperate Edward strips down to his bare essentials, giving a massive crowd of people, not to mention the audience, a gag-inducing   peep show of anemic skin and body glitter. I will refrain from narrating further as not to spoil the experience for any devout fangirl, but then again, the movie is lifted from a book so there's nothing much to spoil. In any case, all the loopholes are negligible since viewers will be glued to the screen, voraciously consuming the clues and revelations being set up for the next big installment.

What makes New Moon way better than Twilight, aside from its seamless match cuts, clean camera work, fast-paced action sequences, and poignant background music, is the fact that it brings back the chilling gothic image of these creatures which is severely lacking in the first movie. This difference transforms this hormone-induced fantasy chick flick into a mildly palatable movie for all audiences.

SPOT.ph Rating: 3 out of 5 Spots â– ŹĂ˘– ŹĂ˘– Ź

Click here to see where the movie is showing.

Username   * required
Security Image Security Image  * required
 
NOTE: SPOT.ph editors reserve the right to moderate and delete comments, without notice, that contain abusive or threatening behavior, contain advertising, spam, profanity or malicious comments.
Filter comments by:
  • Mac May 07 2010 @ 04:28pm Report Abuse
    why does a glittering edward cullen looks like a lost lady g*g* back up dancer..... DAMN YOU stephanie meyer to the 7th circle of hell for destorying the vampire lore!!!
  • VinVin Nov 30 2009 @ 10:21am Report Abuse
    well. I'm a twilight addict. :D and an edward cullen lover. regardless of other people's opinions (which should be respected, nonetheless), i will still maintain my being a fan 'til the end. :D

    http://www.vinvinjacla.com
  • Hayden2 Nov 28 2009 @ 05:00pm Report Abuse
    I thought this movie was a step up from the first - admittedly not hard, as Twilight was abysmal. However, by the end of New Moon the musical score was unbearable. Sad because the soundtrack is really good.

    We are smart people and don't need to be told how to feel at every moment of a film, especially when it is not much better than bad elevator music.
  • Kit Ono Nov 27 2009 @ 02:17am Report Abuse
    On another note with more relevance to the article, I do think that Dakota Fanning was marvelous. Her presence took up the whole screen and even lingered afterward. Brava.
  • Kit Ono Nov 27 2009 @ 02:09am Report Abuse
    @Tracy: I actually like your comments.

    And besides, no matter how intense the bashing, criticizing, condemning and all these we throw at Twilight, it's too late. The fanaticism is already there, with no sign of fading any time soon.

    Twilight is such a peculiar phenomenon (yes, the term). Here it is, a novel overly drowning in adverbs, cliches and sap yet it has evolved into this craze grave enough for us to even discuss about.

    Twilight has some merits. Yes, some. After all, if it had been absolutely barbaric material, it would have gained zero response from anyone. Maybe if the execution and some elements are altered, it would have been a bomb. But alas as displayed here, you can't have everything.

    My favorite definition of Twilight is that it's an extremely guilty pleasure. It's a breather, for those moments when one simply wants to read while suspending judgment and critique and turn on the mush and cheese receptors. Read it, take in the over-sentimental lines, the drama, and when you're done with it you can go back to reading Longinus, Proust and Foucault.

    But oh well, Twilight says a lot about our readers today.
  • Tracy Nov 25 2009 @ 06:50am Report Abuse
    Sigh. Is it really that difficult to allow other's to have a different opinion? That's the whole beauty of diversity. We can consider, learn from, or at the very least, respect other's opinions. We have all have different personal experiences that cause to feel the way we do. I think the moment I matured the most in my life is when I was able to stand back and accept that people may think differently from me and instead of it being something negative, it was actually something I could grow from.

    Perhaps a comment of "I disagree with you but respect your opinion" would have been nice, instead I got dogged on and told to get a life. If people honestly think that because someone enjoyed a book that they didn't, this means they lead a 'superior' life, this makes me sad.

    Perhaps some people would be happier if they could form a committe on what it considered to be "thrash" and make sure no one can say they enjoyed it. I'm sure it won't be too difficult finding members. :)

    Sigh. And I used to think these little discussion groups on Spot were a cool place to share opinions.
  • Angela Nov 25 2009 @ 01:54am Report Abuse
    @Tracy. Let's call a spade a spade.
    It is not literary pretension to call the twilight series thrash because that is what it is.
    The writing is awful, the characters have zero depth, the plot is nonexistent,and to top it all off, it is staunchly anti-feminist.

    No amount of truisms or sob-stories can refute the fact that twilight is *OBJECTIVELY* a bad series. And, at the end of the day, after all the mental gymnastics are done, what you're doing is simply defending bad taste.
  • Rush Nov 24 2009 @ 04:42pm Report Abuse
    @ gecko. it seems like you haven't read the book yet. he just not exposed himself to the sunlight but to the humans as well so that the Volturi will get mad and will kill him. in the book, humans doesn't know that vampires do exist, thus, by exposing himself to the humans will give the Volturi reason to end Edward's life. and you're right, they will just glitter like diamonds under sunlight, it wont kill him, but the Volturi will do the job. so there...
  • cindy Nov 24 2009 @ 12:52pm Report Abuse
    well, well, well, I guess Catherine the twilight director is the best director to direct the twilight saga,..why they need to abandoned her in fact she's the bests director to direct it not like this new guy whose their new director...I think in the new moon movie they must put some or I'LL say a lot of music background just what the first movie did..
    MUSIC GIVES MORE INTERESTING, EXCITEMENT, LIFE TO ANY MOVIE..SO I PREFER NEXT TIME THEIR NEW DIRECTOR IN NEW MOON WILL NOTICE IT..I LOVE TWILIGHT MOVIE MORE THAN NEW MOON..
  • Diana Nov 24 2009 @ 12:10pm Report Abuse
    Yeah, get a life.
  • Tracy Nov 24 2009 @ 11:50am Report Abuse
    The enthusiasm of tween fans has always been a force to reckon with. When they decided they loved boy bands & Britney Spears, the whole world became a pop playground. Their influence is obviously huge but it's not something I run from in fear. Now if Justin Timberlake or Britney became President, I would see your point. But until their enthusiasm, in this case, for books, becomes an actual threat, as in you LITERALLY believe that they will force libraries and bookstores to classify the Twilight series as Classic Literature then you are reading a little too much into the hype.

    I would have assumed that it went without saying that Shakespeare's place in history is secure. Do their opinions truly bother you that much? Since the Twilight-mania may last for a few more years, I'm afraid you may be in an extended state of disgruntlement. That might not be very pleasant for the people around you, so maybe we should all try to let bygones be bygones. In due time, the next fad will begin and we can all moan and complain about that.
  • gecko Nov 24 2009 @ 11:24am Report Abuse
    ... No one is declaring Ms. Meyer the next Shakespeare, or demanding her books be placed under ‘Classics’ in bookstores. ...

    You should ask the fans.
  • Tracy Nov 24 2009 @ 11:15am Report Abuse
    Why escape into fantasy? Aren't all forms of media seen as an 'escape' in one aspect? Films, television, music, and even the arts all offer an outlet to get away from the real world, for a minute, for an hour, for as long as the person chooses.

    I find it difficult to believe that a person could live his whole life without ever feeling the need or desire to lose themselves in another world. In fact, it's sad to think of a life where imagination and fantasy do not exist. Rather than showing an absence of a "life", I would counter that it shows a life filled with curiosity and the hope for something more.

    I will agree that these books aren't the most academic novels out there, but if I had to spend every minute of my life concerning myself with only things considered "academic" and yes even "intelligent", I think I would lose my mind.

    Should I read only the classics, watch nothing but documentaries and make sure my subscription to National Geographic never expires? Sure, it would be a completely noble and worthy existence, but one that would leave me completely exhausted and dissatisfied. There is room for romance, frivolity, silliness, and yes fantasy, in everyone's life.

    Every form of media has it's dark horse. TV - Reality shows; Music - Pop; Movies - Trashy teen films (in my opinion), but they are popular because they fit a niche in society. So why not try doing what I do when I see Wowowee or The Buzz on TV? I change the channel. It's as simple as respecting what others may like, learning what I don't, and exercising my power to control it.
  • Dita Nov 24 2009 @ 07:29am Report Abuse
    if your life is boring, then why not get a life? why escape into fantasy? especially when your low-quality stimulus does not challenge or increase your intelligence. what a waste of your time when you could be out there living an actual non-boring life. or, just read better, more well-written books.
  • Tracy Nov 24 2009 @ 05:39am Report Abuse
    These books are popular because they offer a fantasy to those who are stuck, leading lives of quiet desperation. Many people - women and men - live through days that barely mean anything. Wake up, go to work, come home, eat dinner, pay bills, sleep, wake up, and do it all over again.

    We feel we are not remarkable in any way, not amazingly talented, beautiful or a genius. We feel that are lives are just passing by, day by passion-less day, and in the grand scheme of things, the lives we led do not even matter.

    But what if one day, your mind-numbing, average life changes? What if you fall into a world of fantasy, legends and find a love so unbelievable you simply could not stand to let it end? Yes, it's not sane. Yes, it's not logical. Yes, it's not possible. But life finally means something, and as some people say 'you are not truly living, until you have found something you would die for.'

    I've been reading novels since I was 8. If I was missing, you could find me in a library. By age 12, I was reading anything from The Baby-sitter's Club to Jane Austen to Gabriel Garcia Marquez, but I am NO book snob. I think every novel has at least ONE thing to teach us, and for that reason, I love almost every book I read.

    Sure, I'll sound smart if I say these books are trash and spout some authors to demonstrate how brilliant my taste is (cough, what, cough), but I would be lying if I said I wasn't entertained.

    Maybe the trick is to remember these books are a FANTASY. No one is declaring Ms. Meyer the next Shakespeare, or demanding her books be placed under 'Classics' in bookstores. They have obviously struck a chord with many people. Who are we, and who is anyone, for that matter, to judge what makes a personal experience worthy or unworthy?

    It's simple. If you like the books, great. If you don't, great. There is no need to make one opinion more valid than the other.
  • what Nov 24 2009 @ 01:00am Report Abuse
    @intense_me

    Try reading REAL literature you silly little girl.
    Pick up some Bradbury, Gaiman, Vonnegut, Moore, or hell, if you want to go full-on pseudo-intellectual, Tommy-boy Pynchon and James Joyce.

    Stop reading children's books if you're over the age of 18 (or at least stop being so proud about it).
  • blabla Nov 23 2009 @ 07:55pm Report Abuse
    new moon is way better than twilight. I agree. I read the book, though it's good, it tends to be too girly sometimes.
  • new moon Nov 23 2009 @ 07:40pm Report Abuse
    haha..this is a lot better than twilight!!

    good job mr.director!
  • ynah Nov 23 2009 @ 07:21pm Report Abuse
    he'd die by exposing himself to people, it's against a vampire rule. not the sun will kill him literally but the superiors would.God! this movie is not for logicless
  • IamPinoy Nov 23 2009 @ 05:47pm Report Abuse
    I think the only reason the Twilight series is really popular is the number of teens and tweens in the world (plus their hormones). I was able to finish the whole series but I was barely awake most of the time especially New Moon. I had to re-read the first chapter 3 times before I was able to finish the book. I only read the last two books (Eclipse and Breaking Dawn) because I didn't want my money to go to waste. I tried analyzing why this book just didn't do anything for me and the answer is one word: HUMOR. It goes from one cheessy line to another reminding me why I choose to sleep rather than endure the teleseryes/telenovelas every night. The books does not contain one freaking witty remark or if it does it fails big time.

    The movies are decent enough but again there is not much depth in the material so you should probably leave all logic behind when you read or watch the movie.

    Also can someone tell me why Edward and Bella are so in love with each other? Other than Edward sparkles in the sunlight and he seems to love the smell of Bella's blood? Thinking back I could not recall any meaningful conversation between the two of them (excluding the mushy lines they throw at each other about lambs and lions). Plus (spoiler alert) getting married and pregnant at 18 or 19? Really?? Nice message to your the millions and billions of tweens and teens reading the books (snickers)

    But ultimately Stephen King sums up what I feel about Twilight.

    The difference between Jo Rowling and Stephenie Meyer is that Jo can write...
  • intense_me Nov 23 2009 @ 05:37pm Report Abuse
    nothing can beat jk rowling of course.. sadly im done reading all jk rowling's work so maybe switch to another taboo masterpiece which is stephenie meyers'...no choice
  • Realistic Nov 23 2009 @ 12:29pm Report Abuse
    Face it, teens just want to have sex. Let's not be hypocrites. Teach them to be safe!
  • Cookie Nov 23 2009 @ 12:23pm Report Abuse
    at the very least, this book series made young people read.

    Of course HP is way better.
  • Crabbypatty Nov 23 2009 @ 10:38am Report Abuse
    I'm not anywhere near pubescent, but this whole Twilight business makes me wish I could be 13 again, so that I could be st*p*d and like it
  • iman Nov 22 2009 @ 11:21pm Report Abuse
    Stephanie Myer's writing and style is way out of the league. I just can't seem to grasp what's the fuss all about.
  • team jacob Nov 22 2009 @ 08:49pm Report Abuse
    i admit i watched it to see jacob's hot new bod! we all did! hehe
  • ;p;z Nov 22 2009 @ 05:59pm Report Abuse
    and if you really read the book..

    its expected that you'll only see edward at the first and last part of the story, unless you want the screenwriter to make up with scenes just to make edward's appearance in the film to stay longer

    if you really like a 100% edward cullen movie.. then ask summit if they could also make an adaptation of Midnight Sun.

    just like Twilight.. but in edward's point of view
  • lolz Nov 22 2009 @ 05:55pm Report Abuse
    hahahaha..

    good read?

    of all the twilight series.. new moon is far the worst ever

    and what's with bella's character? so annoying

    the only reason i've done reading that book is because my sister told me that eclipse and breaking dawn are worth the read,

    haay..

    STEPHEN MAYER IS NOTHING NEAR JK ROWLING!
  • Cookie Nov 22 2009 @ 03:37pm Report Abuse
    Edward did that to expose himself to the crowd, to make a scene. because vampire rule is never to expose their secret, their existence. But by revealing to the mortals their secret, he will be executed.

    If you're an edward fan, you'll be dissappointed bcause he's not around much. :(

    The book series is a good read, if you'd like to relieve your high school life/lovelife. It's for the young/teen people so don't be so critical.
  • vomit Nov 22 2009 @ 12:51pm Report Abuse
    If you actually watched the movie or read the book (which I did unfortunately), Gecko, you'd know why it isn't really a plot hole (Edward does not strip naked to die due to sunlight). However, that doesn't really make the book (and the movie's main Edward--centric conflict) any better.
  • gecko Nov 22 2009 @ 11:00am Report Abuse
    dculd = could
  • gecko Nov 22 2009 @ 10:59am Report Abuse
    I will spoil this for you Dra. ClumsyEmogirl:

    He wants to die, so he strips naked in the middle of an Italian square/plaza. Plothole: how dculd he die when sunlight only makes him glitter?

    I don't see the logic behind: "I don’t think the novel is boring, especially if you like reading books."

    I like (!) reading books, but Twilight is poorly-written, I won't go anywhere near it. If you are really a book-lover, caring about the future of literature, you'd stay away.
  • Dra Bella Nov 22 2009 @ 09:48am Report Abuse
    Excuse me! But I don't think the novel is boring, especially if you like reading books. I remember I can't stop reading the Twilight novels even during conferences.

    I'm yet to watched the movie so no comment for now.
  • Kapuso Online Nov 21 2009 @ 04:33pm Report Abuse
    just watched new moon - well what can i say --- it's kinda expected, a boring novel equals a boring film!!!

    i feel sorry to the screenwriter, how much he squeeze his mind to come up with a good story for the film since the book has nothing to offer

    and the new moon soundtracks are cool but the musical score is not... and for me.. the Twilight director is much better that this new guy.. haay
  • Eden Nov 21 2009 @ 03:25pm Report Abuse
    Borrowed Ideas + Cliche Teen Romance = Twilight Saga
1 to 20 of 35
 
Search    ARTICLE   ESTABLISHMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Is the problem today resolved already?

Martin - February 7, 2012 | 3:36pm

READ THE ARTICLE - Another MRT technical glitch stalls operations on Tuesday morning, February 7

Tama ka, Netizen. Actually, I have low expectations sa P-Noy administration. Ayusin lang nila MRT, OK na ako. Kaso MRT nga lang di pa maayos! Ano ba...

Angry MRT Bird - February 7, 2012 | 2:20pm

READ THE ARTICLE - Another MRT technical glitch stalls operations on Tuesday morning, February 7

the LRT/MRT service is detrimental to the health of the public. halos araw araw kasi maha-high blood ka.

Netizen - February 7, 2012 | 1:37pm

READ THE ARTICLE - Another MRT technical glitch stalls operations on Tuesday morning, February 7

oh puhleese... noynoy had all the time in the world to do this when he was not yet President. why only now??? is this part of the "it's more fun in...

Netizen - February 7, 2012 | 1:30pm

READ THE ARTICLE - "I don't think we're playing around," says Grace Lee when asked if she sees her relationship with P-Noy "pushing through"

EAT+DRINK
CHECK IT OUT: Agahan in Makati
A new place where you can stuff yourself with all-day breakfast food
SHOPPING+SERVICES
CHECK IT OUT: Jing Si Books and Cafe in Binondo
Exploring Binondo? Check out this haven for books and CDs on Buddhist teachings, eco-friendly products with a small cafe serving vegetarian food.
EAT+DRINK
10 Steals and Deals This Week
Coffee-and-cake combos at Chocolate Fire for P200, chicken-all-you-can at Max's Las Piñas for P199, and more!
EAT+DRINK
CHECK IT OUT: Cafe Publico in Greenhills
This cozy gelateria serves funky flavors like Thai Tea, Black Samurai, and Peanut Butter and Jelly.
ENTERTAINMENT
10 Movies to Watch This Month
Daniel Craig and Rooney Mara in The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo, George Clooney in The Descendants, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace in 3D, and more!
EAT+DRINK
CHECK IT OUT: Ramen Cool in Kapitolyo, Pasig
Liempo and salmon in your ramen bowls? Ramen Cool says it can be done.
VIDEOS
Lourd de Veyra's modeling debut in Cosmo's January issue
Lourd trades t-shirts for sixties-style suits.
VIDEOS
Ford Supermodel of the World Danica Magpantay stars in her...
The young model is Globe Tattoo@Home's newest brand ambassador.
VIDEOS
Videos of Ate Vangie, the "Pinoy Siri" go viral
Meet "Vangie," the Taglish-speaking virtual assistant who can help you combat Manila traffic jams, make Pinoy spaghetti, and more.
VIDEOS
Juana Change pokes fun at the "little girl" in latest...
"They are plotting to kill me," says Juana Change as Gloria Arroyo in new vid.
VIDEOS
Juana Change's Christmas 2011 Video: "Iba't-ibang Mukha ng Pasko"
No nega vibes here: Juana Change parties with kids in her new Christmas video.
VIDEOS
Bea Alonzo gets groovy in Preview's holiday video
Join Bea and The Bang Bangs as they backtrack to the '60s in this very mod holiday music vid!
VIDEOS
Be the life of the party with Petra Mahalimuyak's latest...
This 19-year-old comedian shows off dance moves that would put J.Lo to shame.
VIDEOS
Charice tackles bravery in latest video, “Louder”
Now more grown up than ever, Charice shows the world how to soldier on despite adversity.