Back to top
Court junks rebellion case vs Ampatuans, ASEAN has no power to help massacre kin
Published on: Mar 30, 2010 - 1:39pm

After finding no probable cause to indict the Ampatuans for rebellion, a Quezon City court ordered the release of several Ampatuan clan members including the family patriarch, former Maguindanao Gov. Datu Andal Ampatuan Sr., and suspended Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao Gov. Zaldy Ampatuan, reports

However, the Ampatuans are to remain in detention because of multiple murder charges against them in connection to the Maguindanao massacre, for which they have a pending trial.

For the latest Philippine news stories and videos, visit GMANews.TV

The Ampatuans were charged with rebellion for allegedly "[commanding] their followers to rise publicly and take arms against the Republic for the purpose of removing allegiance to the government," government prosecutors claimed, according to It was alleged that the uprising was meant to foil their arrest for the Maguindanao massacre. reports that the prosecution based its rebellion charge on four alleged scenarios: "there were no prosecutors on hand to conduct proceedings regarding the November 23 massacre; there were massive formations of armed civilians to resist government troops; the local government units (LGUs) were not functioning because the employees went on mass leave; and the courts were not functioning."

Judge Vivencio Baclig of the Quezon City Regional Trial Court (RTC) Branch 77, who penned the 18-page order releasing the Ampatuans, said no recorded evidence supports the four scenarios.

Baclig said the submitted photos "hardly portray a menacing and violent armed mob poised to undermine governmental authority… In fact, none of the exhibits will show that anyone of the protesters is armed." He also cited statements on the placards on the photos like "We love you Madame President" and "We want due process."

Meanwhile, in Jakarta, Indonesia, more bad news met the families of the massacred journalists at the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights (AICHR) headquarters. The AICHR told them the human rights body could not receive individual complaints such as the petition filed by the families seeking help in bringing the suspects of the massacre to justice and ensuring that compensation is paid to the families left behind, reports ABS-CBN News.

"[Investigation of] individual complaints is not part of the power of AICHR. Not yet," AICHR Indonesia Commissioner Rafendi Djamin told the widow of journalist Joel Parcon, Naomi Parcon, who staged a protest rally in front of the ASEAN headquarters with other rights groups.

Rafendi said, "With all due respect to your families, of course, if it were up to me, I will take it up immediately. But AICHR is composed of 10 countries. This will have to be discussed, especially how we are going to deal with the complaints. I can only say that I will do my best to really strengthen the position of AICHR--our power and mandate. It will take a bit long. I'm really sorry about that."

Rafendi added that a Philippine government official verbally described the Maguindanao massacre to the AICHR as a "domestic issue." Rafendi told reporters, "Human rights is a universal issue."

Lawyer Harry Roque said they would send a formal reply to the AICHR regarding the statement of the Philippine government official.

Forum Asia Executive Dir. Yap Swee Seng said, "If [AICHR] continues to justify not taking up cases on the principle of non-interference, I think this commission will be ineffective and totally non-relevant to the ASEAN peoples who are suffering day to day."

How do you feel about this article?
Total Votes
We Recommend
Username   * required
Security Code Security Code  * required
NOTE: editors reserve the right to moderate and delete comments, without notice, that contain abusive or threatening behavior, contain advertising, spam, profanity or malicious comments.
  • igeramos
    As for ASEAN, they have no balls anyway. They never lifted a finger to save Aung San Suu Kyi from the powerful Burmese military junta.

    The Ampatuans will just continue their reign in Mindanao and guess what, the people will accept them as if nothing happened. This fear and acceptance will be the seed for the future and the continuing cycle of human rights abuse in Mindanao.

    The judicial branch, through Judge Vivencio Baclig was given a chance to shine in this case. But he just squandered and wasted the opportunity. Like the Ampatuan Massacre, he will be forgotten and his lackluster career as a judge will leave not a single legacy to his children and family. He is a pathetic, sad and tragic man.

    I hope this judge can still sleep soundly at night with a conscience as dark as coal.
    Mar 31 2010 @ 02:26am     Reply  
  • lovefool
    Why am I not surprised at all that this will happen? My heart goes out to the family of the 57 people that were killed, and the family they left behind. Apparently, justice has left this country a long time ago, to the delight of people like Fruity Loop here.
    Mar 31 2010 @ 12:27am     Reply  
  • Fruity Loop
    Hahaha! That's what's up! That's what you get for assuming too much! Never judge a book by its cover. Yes, this saying is cliche' but the sad thing is, you people still keep on doing it. And to think, legislators, candidates for public positions keep on preaching about education. True, there are budgets that have been allocated for the education of the people, nevertheless, despite the amount of education the people get, they never get any smarter. Good bye rebellion! Set free the governor! For the love of Shariff Aguak! Hurrah! People like Gerry here will die with envy. Too bad. While you people are at it, eat your hearts out. Peace.
    Mar 30 2010 @ 09:10pm     Reply  
  • Gerry
    So are we just going to forget that 57 people were killed?
    Mar 30 2010 @ 06:45pm     Reply  
1 to 4 of 4