(SPOT.ph)Ā Before I share my take on Jo Koyās performance at the Golden Globes, there are a few things about me you need to know:
1. Taylor Swift has consistently been one of the top artists in my Spotify Wrapped for the past few years.
2. Iām not a fan of Jo Koyās humor. I enjoyed a few of his routines when I first saw them, but they got old fast.
3. I have a soft spot for comediansāno matter how cringe and/or offensive they may be. Iām of the opinion that as a civilized society we must allow comedians to be cringe and/or offensive, as long as theyāre aware that theyāre cringe and/or offensive, and as long as their being cringe and/or offensive comes from a non-malicious, purely artistic place.
Also read:Ā In Jo Koyās Defense: Whoopi Goldberg, Steve Martin + More Rally Behind Golden Globes Host
Jo KoyĀ and the Golden Globes
My (unpopular) take then: Jo Koyās Golden Globes performance wasnāt that bad. It actually gets a little bit better somehow upon rewatching, if you can. Some jokes fell flat, and some were lazy, but I think the monologue started to go downhill only when he confronted the crowd and then immediately apologized for not receiving the reaction heād expected. I would have admired him more if he hadnāt cared at all and just stuck to his guns.
And it was a tough crowd. Not his crowd either. Jo Koyās usual audience consists of Filipinos (or Filipino-Americans), and much of his humor relies on, for lack of an exact term, ārelatability.ā He typically jokes about Filipino culture, food, parenting, accent, etc. In short, his audience are those he is theoretically on the same level with.
I use ātheoreticallyā here because of course the material conditions Jo Koy deals with are different from those of the average Filipino. I donāt think heās ever made a joke about getting stuck in traffic or mugged in an alley. We can get academic here, but letās keep it simple: in his typical routines Jo Koy tries to construct a relatable persona.
And that persona was completely out of place among that audience composed of Hollywood demigods. He couldnāt do his normal shtick: how could he possibly relate to these powerful personalities, and vice versa? This disconnect contributed to the awkwardness of Jo Koyās performance.
So what did he do? Punched up. Made fun of such celebrities. Which isnāt really a new thing at awards ceremonies like the one he was hosting. Thatās why I found it funny when some people got upset because they thought his jokes were āoffensive.ā My gripe with Jo Koyās performance is not that it was offensive but that it was the usual.
Ricky Gervais, for instance, has hosted the show five times, and every time he was brutal. In his 2020 gig alone he accused the audience of being friends with convicted sex offenders Harvey Weinstein and Jeffrey Epstein. He practically called the uber-famous hypocrites to their faces. And thatās why itās amusing to see people angry at Jo Koy for being offensive when they seem to want a return of Gervais.
Unlike Jo Koy, though, Gervais got away with it because heās an A-lister himself. Conversely I couldnāt help but feel that the audience reacted to Jo Koy the way they did mainly because they didnāt see him as a member of their group yet. You could almost feel a āWho are you?ā or āHow dare you make fun of us?ā vibe. A sense of smugness.
And here we can get academic again and argue that Gervaisās criticism of Hollywood is somewhat toothless because heās part of it in the first placeāwhereas Jo Koyās, although not as sharp, is actually less par for the course and hence more valid.
Also read:Ā Opinion: Jo Koy, Itās Time to Take Stock of Your Life Choices
Jo Koy on Taylor Swift at the Golden Globes
Now, the elephant in the room: Jo Koyās Taylor Swift joke was lame, sure, but it was so tame. Gervais, or even any self-aware Swiftie for that matter, could have come up with a more biting joke. Something about her being a billionaire, you know, or her private jetāand these are only the easy ones. I have a good joke about Taylor Swift actually, but I wonāt share it because I donāt want to upset anyone. But if youāre already upset, refer back to item number 1 above.
My point is, and I say this with all the sensitivity I can muster: I donāt think Jo Koyās Taylor Swift joke was about her being a woman. It was more about her fame and the NFL exploiting it. And perhaps we should be more judicious in using words like āmisogynisticā and āracist.ā Letās reserve them for things that are truly misogynistic and racist and worthy of our outrage. Because if everything is misogynistic, racist, and outrageous, nothing is.
Jade Mark CapiƱanes teaches media and writing and is the author of a collection of short fiction called How to Grieve published by Everythingās Fine.