(SPOT.ph) I got upset with my students only once during my five-year teaching stint, and Iām not even sure I could call it being upset. Before I let them know it,Ā I even sought their permission. āGuys, puwede ba ako manermon?āĀ
It wasnāt your usual sermon. You could call it, as kids might say these days, ānonchalant.ā I wasnāt OA, didnāt raise my voice. I didnāt lecture them on my credentials andĀ for sure I didnāt go live on TikTok.Ā
It was homeroom time. Our session should have already startedĀ but only a few have shown up. It took about 5 to 10 more minutes for more kidsĀ to trickle in. Some of them walked in laughing, food and drinks in hand, clearly nonchalant about being super late.Ā
I simply leaned against the teacherās table inĀ front and theĀ chatter simmered down when they noticed my silence. At doon ko lang ginalaw ang baso. Ā
In the calmest way possible, I reminded them to respect our schedule. I even threw in some jokes, like an inside joke about this large and vaguely threatening signage put up by a masonic group near our school: āAlways attend stated meeting.ā
The viral TikTok teacher's trick no longer works
I know what youāre thinking. They disrespected my position as a teacher but I didnāt scold them properly. Iām such a pushover. I even asked for their consent if I could get madāclearly a sign of being āwokeā! Kaya hindi na natatakot ang mga bata sa mga guro ngayon e! Dati, konting likot mo lang, lilipad ang eraser sa mukha mo. Ngayon, sa sobrang feeling entitled nila, deserve nga nilang tapunan ng blackboard! Blah blah blah 90s kids lang malakas!Ā
But if I just parroted those old reprimands, I thought, what was the point of my being a teacher? Theyāve heard it all before, drilled into them at home and school, and yet here we are. Clearly, theĀ old method doesn'tĀ work.Ā
The alleged teacher on TikTok who livestreamed herself chastising her students? It was certainly an imperfect moment, and it was equally imperfect that she felt the need to broadcast it for everyone to see and criticize her.Ā
But if we can speculate a bit, maybe she did it because of our collective tendency to broadcast every aspect of our lives. Maybe it was her way of seeking support. Maybe she felt that only through TikTok Live could she express her frustrations with her job. She couldnāt do that in real life to those running DepEd, could she?Ā She had to be ānice.āĀ
Flipping the roles
Maybe she also saw that problematic āsatiricalā Vincentiments video where a student berates her teacher. You know, the one where the student, played by that bootleg Jihyo, is OA: she bursts into a fit of rage while slowly undressing. Then thereās a twist: it was all just fantasy, like it was everything she wanted to say all along but couldnāt. This time, the viral teacher just flipped the roles.Ā
Maybe the greatest lapse in judgment of the viral "teacher" is to think weāre living in Darryl Yapās cinematic universe. But in real life, we couldnāt be pure id.Ā As Freud teaches us, thereās always a chasm between what we want to say (id) and what we must say (superego). And in that gap (ego) is where we can choose what to sayāwhere we, with great difficulty, do our best to be less imperfect. Weāre all just trying, you know.Ā
I got whacked on the knee with a stick in front of the class when I was in grade 2 because my crush, who I thought also had a crush on me, listed me as ānoisy.ā (It was my earliest experience of romantic disillusionment.) Did I turn out fine? Sure. But was it because of the smacking? I donāt think so.Ā
I simply grew up and realized a lot of things, like we should never mistake respect for fear, or that we should never use āreal talkā as an excuse for being mean.Ā
When I gave my class a dose of real talk, I focused on the time weād agreed to meet. That was the thing they had to respect. I didnāt order them to respect me. If they respected me, fine, thank you very much, but I always felt it cringe to ask my students, or anyone for that matter, to respect me. Teacher or not, you donāt demand respect. It should be voluntarily given to you. The moment I required respect, things would get weird. Feelings would get involved.Ā
Time, on the other hand, has no feelings. That day, between my Gen Z students and me, only time stood perfect and impartial. So, if there was something we could all agree on, it was to respect time. āWednesdays, 2-3 PMā would always be āWednesdays, 2-3 PM.ā I, their teacher, could act high and mighty and authoritative today but might commit something horrible tomorrowāand it would make them thinkĀ I was a hypocrite. It could further their disillusionment with teachers, 90s kids, boomers, adults.Ā
A teachable moment
The lesson I wanted to teach that Wednesday afternoon in homeroom wasnāt simply about authority. It was about a deeper thing we all share, whether teachers or students: humanity.Ā
Weāre all imperfect, but we shouldnāt use that as an excuse to be imperfect all the time. My students were terribly imperfect that afternoon, but I didnāt use it as an excuse to be terribly imperfect in front of them too.Ā
When I was in grade 2, the same teacher who smacked me did something I could never forget. While she was lecturing, I made a joke related to what she said, which made my classmates laugh. To me, that felt good. (Even then, I wanted the approval of people, you see.) I wonāt repeat the joke because today it could be a solid ground for being canceled. Suffice it to say it was the reason, right after class, my teacher asked me to go with her to the teacherās corner.Ā
She sat me down. She didnāt tell me she felt disrespected. She focused on why joking about the thing I joked about was not a good thing to do. She explained to me, calmly, why my joke was offensive. I felt very imperfect at the time, but with all the kindness and patience I have since tried to emulate, my teacher made me feel it was okay. We could always do better next time.Ā
Jade Mark CapiƱanes teaches media and writing and is the author of a collection of short fiction calledĀ How to Grieve published by Everythingās Fine.